Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Iain F Macleod's avatar

Thanks for your comment, Neil - I think you've got a great attitude to it, to keep on trying. Tim Armstrong writes about this issue and I will link to an interesting paper below. You're not alone in this. Have you found good ways to mitigate it?

I sometimes throw out signals in a conversation which starts in English with someone I don't know - small phrases, adding "ma tha", then gradually adding a little more until I get enough back to feel ok asking if they'd like to speak Gàidhlig. But even then, people might have different reasons to not want to speak it there and then, and although there is a small social cost, the benefits outweigh it.

Tha fàilte romhad sgrìobhadh san dà chànan an seo.

Tim Armstrong's paper:

https://pureadmin.uhi.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/3570947/Alt_G_idhlig_2_SGS_aon_ghdar_2.pdf

Neil MacArthur's avatar

Great stuff. You can't tell by looking who has Gaelic and who doesn't. I go through periods of greeting in Gaelic and seeing what I get back and sometimes lose heart. I always try again though and as a learner it can be hard to find conversation especially when you know it's out there.

No posts

Ready for more?